An open letter asking NHS England to keep its code open.

We believe that this document is fully human-written.

Hacker News Article AI Analysis

View story on Hacker News

Content Label

Human

AI Generated

Human

100%

Window 1 - Human

An open letterasking NHS Englandto keep its code open Code paid for with public money should be open to the public. This principle is enshrined in the UK Government Design Principles and the NHS Service Standard. It is now being walked back. We are signing this to restate the case. Add your signature → Published1 May 2026 StatusOpen for signatures Signatures9 signatures so far Andrew NesbittSoftware Developer and Researcher (Ecosyste.ms)Daniel RoeCore team lead (Nuxt)Heidar BernhardssonMiranda HeathResearcher (University of Edinburgh)Misha GorodnitzkyTechnical ArchitectMarcus BawGP, Clinical Informatician and Developer (Baw Medical, RCPCH, openEHR International)Paul Robert LloydInteraction designerTheodor VararuSoftware EngineerVlad-Stefan HarbuzMaintainer (Open Source Pledge) Statement We disagree with the NHS technical leadership’s decision to hide the source code of all of their repositories. Making code open source requires more work than keeping it closed. That hard work is the point. It requires a higher bar of quality. It requires processes to proactively find, fix, and monitor for vulnerabilities. It requires identifying risk, and putting barriers in place to contain any damage when things go wrong. But it works like the human immune system: being exposed to threats hardens the attack surface. Closed source allows that work to be skipped. It substitutes obscurity for depth, and obscurity buys you precious little when a sufficiently motivated attacker is involved. Warning We call on NHS England to withdraw the SDLC-8 red line and reaffirm its commitment to the NHS Service Standard Principle 12: “Make new source code open.” If you agree, sign your name using the form below. Submissions are reviewed by hand and you’ll appear on the page once approved.

Window 2 - Human

References NHS Goes To War Against Open Source NHS England rushes to hide software over AI hacking fears NHS Service Standard — Principle 12: Make new source code open NHS England quietly removes open source policy web pages (Digital Health) Don’t be afraid to code in the open: how to do it securely (GOV.UK) Does Mythos mean shutting down your open source repos? (shkspr.mobi) Discourse is not going closed source (Discourse)